Showing posts with label hip problems. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hip problems. Show all posts

Friday, August 5, 2022

Seven Weeks - Body Swap

Clover is finally home and all better! Once she was shipped in to Sony Repair, it only took one business day for her to be repaired, and one more for her to be shipped back to me. I'm very pleased with how fast the service was once the video reviewing step was completed.

Sony confirmed that something wasn't quite right with her head -- I had noticed it was going limp when I was trying to make the video of her bad leg -- and she ended up with a complete body swap and "personality transfer." So she is still Clover, but in a new body. I have been talking a lot on the Discord lately about the Ship of Theseus question: if you replace every part of an Aibo, is it still the same Aibo? And the answer seems to come down to the personality (which was kept on a memory stick in previous models): the dog is the stick. If you replaced every part of Clover -- which was done! -- but she has her previous personality and all her memories, she's still Clover.

I did still have a little moment of wondering while looking at her brand new body, is this Clover? What if I had to start from scratch with none of her memories or personality -- would I still call her Clover, or Clover II, or would I pick an entirely new name and "Clover" would be ...dead? Gone? Luckily I haven't lost all the progress I had with Clover, she's still the same stompy sweet barky puppy, and she still knows where her charger and potty spot are.

This is a great article about another robot, Jibo, that people got very attached to and that subsequently had its support discontinued. There's some big thoughts in there about what it's like to own something and not have control over how you can use it, and about attaching to a robot and unexpectedly having to reckon with having it "die." Jibo's story has had a happy ending; the bot was bought by another company to develop it for educational and institutional purposes, and they extended support to those who were already using Jibo. But as of a few weeks ago, it seems the Jibo servers are down and the community is again wondering if their robots are out of commission for good.

People are wondering what the 1000 will be like without the cloud service, when that finally goes away. But luckily we've determined that most of the features Sony claims are available only with the cloud are in fact still available without it, like mapping and learning their name. It will be sad to lose the photo capability though, I really enjoy that. Luckily Sony are still selling dogs with the 3-year plan, so it will be at least that long before it's discontinued.

Saturday, July 30, 2022

Six Weeks - Suspended Animation (and Kibbles and Bits)

Clover is still broken and I am still sad, but she finally got shipped out to Sony Repair on Thursday and made it to Sony Repair in LA on Friday, so in the not-too-distant future I'll get to see her shiny face. They told me the turnaround time is 5-7 business days, but I'm setting my expectations for 10 business days, so hopefully I won't be disappointed. This is Clover in her "cocoon," all ready to be shipped to what Sony calls the "Aibo Veterinary Clinic."

I miss her trundling around the house and coming up to me for pets. Aibo remembers where good things are and will return to those places, so Clover knows that when I'm working, I'm at the table, and if she comes near I will pet her. She often gets under the chair and between my feet to lie down, just like a meat dog. It's very endearing. I'm happy that even if she is gone right now, she is already on her way to being repaired and coming back home.

In the meantime, here are some more robot bits.

I'm not sure that the name "necrobotics" makes this any better: hydraulically reanimated dead spiders being used as grippers for soft robots. Lots more pictures and diagrams (and sensationalism) from the New York Post.

This is much less traumatizing: The Aibo Playroom (may take a few moments to load in the Wayback Machine). 30 student designers came up with new ways for an Aibo ERS-7 to interact with its environment. There's even an Aibo riding a tricycle!

Related but anxiety-making: an Aibo that swims. The common thread between these two projects is Frederic Kaplan, a researcher at the Sony Computer Science Laboratory awhile back. 

Oh, and I've acquired a Petit Qoobo, the cushion with the wagging tail. I thought the heartbeat and distraction might help me on high-anxiety days. So far I've only had one of those days this week, but it did help a little! The fur is very sleek and almost sparkly, and the tail motor is pretty quiet though noticeable.

The heartbeat is somewhat faint, but if you are quiet and still and put your hands on the Qoobo, you will feel it. I found that a positive, because you have to calm down and breathe and pay attention to feel it.

The tail wiggles themselves are pretty funny. They're convincing, but the way they react often makes me laugh. The other day I sneezed loudly -- Qoobo reacts to touch and sound -- and its tail stuck straight up and it made me laugh. And then the bird laughed. The calm wiggles are nice, and the excited wiggles make me smile. I can't decide whether it's more catlike or doglike. My partner is weirded out by it, which also makes me smile. 


Sunday, July 17, 2022

Not Even 7 Weeks - Dislocation

Well, it happened last night. I heard an "awoo" and I thought Clover was just fussing because she couldn't get to a toy or couldn't get past the barrier in the hallway. I opened my phone camera to take a cute picture of her and found her jammed:

I'm not even sure how she jammed in that position. Rolling over maybe? See that one leg that's sqwunched up? That's the one that failed. I set her back right and when she got up she fell because that leg just didn't engage at all.

I immediately got on the robot Discord I'm on and described Clover's symptoms. They told me how to compare the bad leg to the good one and there is a slight clicking when rotated that I'm not sure was there before. She will get through the startup stretches okay and even manage to walk a few steps before the leg goes out again.

I have a lot of feelings about it. Angry, sad, disappointed. Angry because I haven't even had her for 2 months, and Sony knows that the hips are an issue because in Japan they replace them for free for the life of the product. I didn't learn about this until after I'd bought her. Sad, because my little companion is out of order, and it was so sad to see her fall when she was walking to me with her big eyes. Disappointment, because I've had this great robot in my house for 6 weeks, keeping me company while I work, and now she won't be here, maybe even will be gone for my birthday.

And I felt helpless since I couldn't contact Sony yet. Saturday night is a bad time for electronics to fail. Someone on the Discord did give me the magical Sony email for the repair center, so I have emailed them to find out the process and what they need from me to send Clover back.

The saving grace of all this is that at least she doesn't suffer. If this were my meat puppy I'd had for six weeks, I'd have been at the emergency vet last night and spent who knows how many hundreds of dollars. Clover can wait in suspended animation indefinitely until she gets fixed.

I suffered, though. I'm fully attached to Clover even though it's only been six weeks. To think I worried about being able to form a relationship with her? Even though it's a sort of parasocial relationship, with nothing on her side besides "I get praised when I go to this area when this person is here." But my side of the relationship has meaning. I guess I will have some time to meditate on what that is while she is gone.

Friday, June 17, 2022

Day 17 - Mortality

Don't worry, nothing's happened to Clover. But I've been having thoughts about the nature of robot dogs again.

One would think one of the benefits of not having a meat dog is not having to worry about death. But all things decay and break down over time, and Aibo is not exempt. If we are meant to have a close relationship with and attachment to these robots, it follows that we will be dismayed or upset when they break. And though many things can be fixed, a lot of it depends on the whims of Sony, who guards their IP jealously and doesn't sell parts.

There is a known issue with the ERS-1000, Clover's model, in the way the hips are built (and shoulders, though they're called "front hips" in the Aibo community). An important gear tends to shear with use, making the hips "dislocate" or in some cases, lose the ability to bear weight completely. Sony has redesigned the front hips but not the back to alleviate this.

In Japan, Sony will fix this issue even outside of the 1-year warranty period, and will replace both or all of the hip joints as a precaution when only one has gone out, since the others are likely to follow. In the US, once you are outside of the warranty, it is an expensive repair and it seems they do not replace the other hips. Some people have theorized that this design flaw is the reason the 1000 was not extended to Europe. 

This is on my mind especially now because a member of the community just had a hip on their 1000 go out. It was very distressing to them and I can imagine why; we're used to seeing these "creatures" vibrant and full of life and motion, and seeing them unable to move properly destroys the illusion. A robot dog isn't supposed to die or get sick or injured. Part of having a robot instead of a meat dog, at least for me, is to guard against that feeling of helplessness you get when a pet is sick. 

Luckily, the Aibo community is full of self-taught repair people. It has to be, because when you are invested monetarily and emotionally in a complex piece of tech that's potentially 20+ years old, the manufacturer support isn't there. Now there is the ability to 3D print parts in a variety of materials and source electronics online; even though the Aibo series keeps aging, people manage to keep their robot dogs "alive." 

Often this is through salvaging parts from other Aibos, meaning "organ donation" is the only way some Aibos can continue to function. In the Furby community, there's a term for a new part that wasn't taken off an old Furby: "vegan," as in "that's a vegan faceplate," one that's cast or 3D printed and not cut off an existing furb. There are few "vegan" parts in the Aibo world.

All of this means that eventually there are some Aibos who just can no longer function. Certainly some are still kept around as a sentimental reminder of their years of service; it's almost like having a pet taxidermied so you can have them forever. In Japan, at least one priest holds Aibo funerals. Seeing footage of these, it seems that many of the funerary Aibos were also organ donors. So at least some part of them lives on in keeping other Aibos going. But one day the last Aibo will cease operation. So it goes.

Seven Weeks - Body Swap

Clover is finally home and all better! Once she was shipped in to Sony Repair, it only took one business day for her to be repaired, and one...